Picture SquareSoft attempting to develop a beat 'em up game half a decade before Sega did—a title blending hand-to-hand combat with role-playing mechanics and flashy cutscenes. Now consider this venture was led by a team of the gaming world's most impressive creative minds. Yet, picture the final product falling short than the sum of its parts. This title is The Bouncer, created by DreamFactory and released in North America in March 2001, shortly after the debut of the PlayStation 2.
Yes, Square and Electronic Arts had a brief alliance in the 1990s and early '00s. No, I don't like to recall it. It's akin to finding out your mom used to date your employer.
The Story of an Ambitious Flop
The Bouncer revolves around three bar workers—Sion, Kou, and Volt—who set out to save their abducted friend Dominique from the powerful Mikado Corporation. The action unfolds in the city of Edge, a location with a neon-spangled grittiness that brings to mind the aesthetics of Final Fantasy 7’s Wall Market and Star Wars’s Coruscant underbelly.
An All-Star Creative Team
The game boasted two helmers, each with impressive credits. Takashi Tokita, the mind behind Chrono Trigger and Final Fantasy 4, co-directed. Seichii Ichii, credited with Virtua Fighter and served as game director for the early Tekken titles. With such backgrounds, one would expect the combat to be exceptional.
However, it turns out that the combat might be the worst aspect. This was due to a finicky input scheme and aggressive ragdoll physics that transformed every felled foe into a flailing inflatable figure. Stranger still, each level was extremely brief, frequently concluded in less than a minute. Cinematic sequences comprised nearly the majority of the game's short playtime, meaning skipping them could slash the experience to a just 30 to 45 minutes.
"The Bouncer succeeds in being visually striking," wrote a contemporary reviewer, "yet that shouldn't deceive you into believing that it's particularly enjoyable."
Style Over Substance
While the gameplay wasn't satisfying, reviewers concurred that The Bouncer possessed a unique and eye-catching visual style. The cutscenes represented a noticeable step up from the previous generation. Furthermore, the protagonists were conceived by Tetsuya Nomura of Final Fantasy 7 fame, sporting some incredibly wild turn-of-the-millennium fashion.
- Massive tribal tattoos covered the torso and head of one character.
- The ensemble cast featured a lot of bare chests, duster coats, chunky footwear, and chunky chain necklaces.
- The villainous antagonists wore distinctive bodysuits with a prominent whale tail on the rear.
Most significant of all was the main character, who sports a striking similarity to future hero the keyblade wielder. Though Sion is older, their design is remarkably alike: spiky locks, a crimson top, voluminous pants, and a accessory chain. Their attire boasts a distinctive red and blue with accents of gold.
A Direct Inspiration
In a 2003 conversation with designer Yoji Shinkawa, Nomura admitted this resemblance was entirely intentional. "Since all the other figures are Disney characters, I wanted the protagonist's look to be a kind of 'amalgamation' of all the characters I'd created till then," he said. "So I think he resembles a lot of characters: there's a bit of Cloud, a touch of Tidus, and elements of Sion. I was quite focused on that."
An Enduring Legacy
The Bouncer may not have created its own franchise, but its influence endured…in an indirect way. A quarter century on, its spiritual successor grew into one of the most iconic figures in history, and the prospect of Kingdom Hearts 4 still hyped fans worldwide. And it all might have played out differently if it weren't for that initial design. Here's hoping that the upcoming sequel reintroduces those unforgettable whale tails, whenever it finally launches.